Harry Potter-Inspired Frozen Butterbeer

7 ingredients

Ryan Tyler Cooks

•

July 3, 2026

Ingredients (7)

Butterbeer Syrup Base

butterscotch sundae syrup(3 Tbsp)
Vanilla extract(1 tsp)
Buttermilk(1 Tbsp, Melted)

Frozen Butterbeer

cream soda(1 ½ cups)
Ice cubes(2 cups)
Coffee Mate Harry Potter Butterbeer Flavored Creamer(¼ cup)
* Butterbeer syrup base (from above)

Instructions

Frozen Butterbeer

1. Make the Butterbeer Syrup * In a small bowl, whisk together the butterscotch syrup, melted butter, and vanilla extract until smooth.
2. Blend the Drink * Add the cream soda, ice, Coffee Mate Butterbeer Creamer, and prepared syrup mixture to a blender. * Blend until smooth, thick, and frosty.
Serve * Drizzle additional butterscotch syrup inside the serving glasses. * Pour the frozen butterbeer into the glasses.
4. Finish * Top with whipped cream if desired. * Drizzle generously with more butterscotch syrup. * Serve immediately.
Optional Toppings* Whipped cream* Extra butterscotch syrup drizzle* Pinch of cinnamon

Notes

Ryan Tyler Cooks Tip

For an even richer “theme park” style butterbeer, freeze the cream soda into ice cubes ahead of time and use those instead of regular ice. You’ll get a thicker drink without watering down the flavor.

Subscribe to get my new recipes delivered to your inbox